Mon, October 15, 2012
China > China & World

Japan's duplicitous moves over Diaoyu Island dispute

2012-10-15 22:59:52 GMT2012-10-16 06:59:52(Beijing Time)  SINA English

Last week, Japan and China agreed to hold a new round of bilateral vice ministerial-level talks to seek a breakthrough regarding the Diaoyu dispute. However, at the meantime, Japan also planned to seek international recognition for its claim of sovereignty over the Diaoyu through a "propaganda war".  

Do these duplicitous moves show Japan’s sincerity to resolve the enduring standoff?

China slams Japan’s moves to win support over Diaoyu

Chinese authorities strongly opposed Japan's moves to seek recognition for its claim over the Diaoyu Islands, China's Foreign Ministry said in response to Japanese foreign minister Koichiro Gemba's planned visit to Europe to rally international support.

Whatever Japan propagandizes in the international community will never change the historical fact that it stole and occupied Chinese territory, foreign ministry spokesman Hong Lei said in a regular press briefing Monday.

Also on Monday, Gemba held talks with visiting US Deputy Secretary William Burns over the island row. There is "no such thing as territorial issues between China and Japan" and he hoped the US could understand the stance, Gemba was quoted by Sankei Shimbun as saying.

"Japan's lobbying shows no repentance on the issue and will end up in vain. It should come back to talk with China with more sincerity," said Liu Jiangyong, a professor with the Institute of International Studies, Tsinghua University.

"Japan lacks sincerity in solving the dispute with China via diplomatic measures," said Wang Ping, a researcher at the Institute of Japanese Studies under the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, noting that a fleet review on Sunday was aimed at showing off its military muscle to China.

The Japanese Maritime Self-Defense Force held its triennial fleet review marking the 60th anniversary of the force's establishment in Sagami Bay off Kanagawa Prefecture on Sunday.

A total of 45 Japanese vessels including submarines, combat vessels, 18 aircrafts and some 8,000 troops participated in the parade, and were joined by vessels from the United States, Australia and Singapore.

Some scheduled displays were cancelled due to poor weather and visibility. A Japanese Coast Guard patrol vessel that had planned to attend the ceremony was absent from the proceedings, as it had been sent to the Diaoyu Islands to conduct a patrol mission.

Negotiation best resolution for China-Japan islands row

More than a month after Japan started a bitter territorial row with China over the Diaoyu Islands, Japan has let out signals that it is willing to sit down and talk things through. Negotiation, after all, is the best way to solve disputes in a modern world.

Last week, senior diplomats of the two countries exchanged visits and agreed to hold a new round of bilateral vice ministerial-level talks to seek a breakthrough regarding the Diaoyu dispute, which had already damaged economic relations between Asia's two largest economies.

The Japanese Foreign Ministry said an agreement was reached at a meeting in Tokyo between Shinsuke Sugiyama, head of the Japanese ministry's Asian and Oceanian Affairs Bureau, and Luo Zhaohui, director general of the Chinese Foreign Ministry's Asian Affairs Department.

The Chinese Foreign Ministry said on Friday that China and Japan had launched vice ministerial-level talks over the Diaoyu Islands on Sept. 25, during which China reiterated its stance on the territory and demanded that Japan admit its mistakes.

Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei said Japan should sincerely correct its mistakes and take concrete action while contributing to upcoming talks.

The prospect of new vice ministerial-level talks, about the highest level of diplomatic exchange that could take place to resolve territorial disputes, brings hope to the current quagmire dragging the two countries down in the disheartening global economic outlook.

Fanned by the Diaoyu dispute, huge anti-Japan protests and voluntary boycotts of Japanese products caused trade between China and Japan in the January-September period to fall by 1.8 percent from a year earlier.

Widely canceled trips by Chinese tourists to Japan also dimmed its tourism industry, particularly during the just-concluded "Golden Week" national holiday that encompassed National Day and Mid-Autumn Festival.

Given the prospective economic losses to the two countries and the world at large, negotiating a pact that can protect each other's territorial dignity and be acceptable to both sides would indeed be a "win-win solution."

In fact, people still remember the guideline put up by late Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping and described as "laying aside differences and engaging in joint exploitation."

After all, under this guideline, the Diaoyu Islands had been well taken care of for decades and the two countries had been at peace.

Besides superficial satisfaction, nominal ownership of the uninhabited islands could do no real good to Japan, as China claims sovereignty over the waters and sends ships to patrol them.

The two sides now need to perform a sidestep to ease tensions. It is also important for the United States, a long-time ally of Japan, to honor its commitment of "not taking sides" on the Diaoyu issue.

U.S. Deputy Secretary of State William Burns is visiting Tokyo and meeting with Japanese Foreign Minister Koichiro Gemba before starting a two-day visit to China on Tuesday.

In a meeting with Burns on Monday, Gemba sought U.S. understanding of Japan's position on disputed islands in the East China Sea, according to Japanese media reports. Burns is also scheduled to meet with Chinese officials to "exchange views on bilateral relations and international and regional issues of common concern," spokesman Hong Lei said.

After an extravagant navy showcase on Sunday, Tokyo seems set to proceed in November with a joint drill with the United States that will simulate a "retaking of a remote island from foreign forces."

With the pending outcome of the U.S. presidential election next month, Japan should realize that its over-dependence on the United States risks pushing itself to the edge of isolation from Asian neighbors.

Japanese politicians should be working to mend the holes they have created in bilateral relations with China rather than taking aggression one step further.

For Japan, healthy relations with its neighboring countries are just as important as one with the United States, both economically and strategically.

(Source:Global Times, Xinhua)


Japan plans propaganda war over Diaoyu Islands

Japan's "purchase" of Diaoyu Islands drags down global economic recovery

Japan's attempt to deny China's sovereignty over Diaoyu Islands is one-sided wish: official

High-level discussions target Diaoyu deadlock

China calls for Japanese progress in upcoming talks

People's Daily urges Japan to return to negotiations over Diaoyu Islands

NY Times: The Inconvenient Truth Behind the Diaoyu Islands

Chinese patriot solo-sails into 8 km off Diaoyu Islands

FM spokesman denounces Japan PM’s remark “gangster logic”

More Chinese airlines cancel flights to Japan

Taiwan places Islands ads in U.S. papers

Australia to sign FTA with Japan, a tug-of-war?

China to 'lose out' by Tokyo IMF no-shows: Lagarde

Japan to “compromise a little” with China on island dispute

China urges negotiation as Japan considers improving ties

Annoyed by Noda, China pins hopes on next Japanese leader

Washington does not accept Japan's claims to Diaoyu Islands

Chinese ships will continue Diaoyu patrols: FM spokesman

JAL extends Japan-China flight cuts till Nov 17



Add Your Comments:

Your Name:
Your Country:
(English Only)
Please read our Terms of Service. Messages that harass, abuse or threaten others; have obscene or otherwise objectionable content; have spam, commercial or advertising content or links may be removed.