National and local family planning authorities are investigating a case involving a seven-month pregnant woman in Northwest China's Shaanxi Province who was allegedly forced by the local government to abort her second child.
A media officer with the National Population and Family Planning Commission (NPFPC) told the Global Times Wednesday that the body is probing the matter, which sparked controversy after a graphic image emerged online of the aborted baby lying next to the mother.
"We're trying to get the whole story. If it's true, local family planning authorities will surely be punished severely," said the officer surnamed Qin. Punishment, if required, will be made according to local regulations.
Feng Jianmei, 23, from Zhenping county in Ankang was forced to the hospital and given an injection to kill her unborn baby on June 2 after her family failed to pay a 40,000-yuan ($6,320) fine, according to her family.
Photos showing the mother and dead baby she delivered on June 4 were uploaded online a week after the abortion.
"The county government detained my wife in a rented house on May 30. She almost killed herself out of panic," Deng Jiyuan, Feng's husband, told the Global Times Wednesday.
He said five men forcibly gave Feng a poisonous injection three days later after blindfolding her and forcing her to sign an agreement on the abortion.
His accusations contradicted a statement from the Zhenping county family planning bureau, which denied holding Feng against her will and claimed the abortion was conducted according to law.
Feng, who is originally from the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, does not have a local hukou (household registration) in Shaanxi. The couple has a 6-year-old daughter and is not entitled to a second child based on their situation and the country's family planning policy, according to the announcement released Tuesday.
The bureau alerted the couple about obtaining required documentation in March, including Feng's hukou, which is necessary for a second child application. Feng was eventually persuaded by family planning authorities and agreed to have an abortion, the bureau said.
However, Deng dismissed the county government's account.
"They did not notify us until several days before the injection, when they asked us to bring 40,000 yuan before the deadline they set, which we failed to do," he said.
Neither the township nor county government involved in the case was available for comment Wednesday.
The Shaanxi provincial family planning commission dispatched a team to Zhenping to investigate the case Monday, according to a statement by the provincial government Wednesday.
The enforcement of the family planning policy should be conducted "in accordance with law and in a civil manner," and late abortions should be prevented to ensure the legal rights of pregnant women, said the notice.
"This is intolerably inhumane and an infringement of human rights," said Zhang Kai, a Beijing-based lawyer renowned for speaking out for disadvantaged groups in China.
Zhang told the Global Times that he has received letters from some 20 women forced to have abortions nationwide since he posted about Feng's experience on his microblog.
Online posts about Feng's forced abortion have triggered a torrent of criticism directed at the Zhenping government and sparked debate about the national family planning policy.
The family planning policy was introduced in 1979 to curb negative impacts of the growing population on the country's economy, society, environment and resources.
The policy has prevented 400 million births since its inception, which contributed to the global population reaching 7 billion five years later than expected, according to the NPFPC.
Zhao Baige, a senior official with the NPFPC, told an international conference in October 2009 that effective implementation of the policy has helped lower the overall birthrate in China, not only greatly boosting the county's economy, but also alleviating poverty and ensuring global population stability, protection of resources and energy efficiency.
However, the policy has been questioned and debated over years due to some local authorities, especially in rural areas, trying to curb birthrates by forcing abortions and heavily fining couples who breach it.
Although the national law does not specify punishment for forced abortions, local regulations have made it a tacit practice by applying "remedial measures" to families exceeding the child quota.
"Fines for families with extra children have become a major source of profit for family planning authorities," said He Yafu, an independent demographer.
The fines, dubbed "social fostering fees," allow wealthy families to have multiple children at the cost of poorer women being forced to have abortions, he said.
Media reports said in May that the total number of social fostering fees collected by family planning authorities nationwide reached an estimated 20 billion yuan per year, but the government has failed to explain its expenditure.
Most people in rural areas have more than one child because they need children to care for them in their senior years, He said, adding the birthrate would be better controlled if the government improved social insurance and pension policies for rural dwellers.
The current national Population and Family Planning Law stipulates that governments should not infringe on people's personal rights and property when conducting family planning.
Gu Xiulian, former chairwoman of the All-China Women's Federation, said at a press conference in 2005 that forced abortions are illegal and a work code of the family planning authorities also bans the detention and assault of women who breach the policy.
Comments on Sina Weibo:
@郎小君： Why can’t someone mull at will to others? If the aborted fetus was to be a member of their family, would these local family planning officials still instruct the mother to get an abortion? Why can’t they just spare the fetus that is soon to be born?
@云层之上永远阳光灿烂： Poor fetus! How could the mother make the decision to abort it? It must be as painful as separating one’s bone from their flesh.
@魏晓艳： It might do great harm to the physical condition of the mother, who was seven months pregnant and forced to have an abortion. It is very possible she might not be able to get pregnant any more. It is not just that simple to have an abortion since the fetus is already seven months old. It is not fair to the unborn child either.
@阿杰： This is too inhumane! Some local government officials ignore the livelihood of the public for the sake of their political achievements. The local family planning officials might resort to forcible ways in asking the mother to have an abortion.
@为伊宽带： The family planning policy should not be blamed if it is carried out legally. But some local government officials make use of the policy to extract money; therefore, they should receive severe punishment for their illegal actions.
A mother in Ankang, Shaanxi Province who was seven months pregnant was reportedly forced to undergo an abortion at the instruction of local family planning officials. Full story